counterfeiting trademarks

Combating counterfeit products - strategies and tactics

  • 25 April, 2024
  • Nyall Engfield

Part I: Combating counterfeit products

Combating counterfeit products is a significant challenge for brands, especially on large online platforms like Amazon. There are several strategies and legal actions that a products company can take to protect their brand and prevent the sale of counterfeit goods:

1. Brand Registry and Intellectual Property Protection

  • Amazon Brand Registry: Companies should enroll in Amazon's Brand Registry program, which provides tools to help protect registered trademarks. The program gives companies more control over product listings with their brand name, including the ability to remove counterfeit listings.
  • Trademark Registration: Ensure that the company's trademarks are registered in the jurisdictions where they sell products. This registration provides legal leverage to enforce trademark rights against counterfeiters. We can help with a US application, which is generally viewed as the most important market for online selling.

2. Monitoring and Reporting

  • Proactive Monitoring: Regularly monitor online platforms for unauthorized sellers and counterfeit products. This can be done manually or by using specialized software that scans for violations.
  • Utilize Platform Tools: Use the tools provided by platforms like Amazon for reporting suspected counterfeits. Amazon, for instance, has an efficient system for stakeholders to report and remove counterfeit listings through their Brand Registry.

3. Legal Actions

  • Cease and Desist Letters: Sending a cease and desist letter to suspected counterfeiters is a common first step. This letter warns the infringer to stop their activities and remove the counterfeit goods from sale, under threat of further legal action.
  • Litigation: If cease and desist letters are ineffective, companies can file a lawsuit for trademark infringement. Successful litigation can result in court orders to stop the sale of counterfeit products and, potentially, monetary compensation for damages caused by the counterfeits.
  • To frame an action against counterfeit products on an online platform, you would first need to establish that the defendant's activities constitute tortious activity. This could be done by demonstrating that the defendant's offers to sell counterfeit products on their online stores were directed towards residents of a particular jurisdiction. Next, you would need to show that the defendant's conduct was willful. This could be supported by evidence of the defendant's failure to appear in court, or by showing that the defendant continued to sell counterfeit products even after being notified of their infringing conduct Ideavillage Prods. Corp v. 123LOPF//V, 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 239765. You would also need to demonstrate that the defendant's activities have caused harm. This could be done by showing that the defendant's sales of counterfeit products have resulted in lost revenue or damage to the reputation of the plaintiff's brand Ideavillage Prods. Corp v. 123LOPF//V, 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 239765. In addition, you could argue that the defendant's activities have a broad scope of operations, especially if the defendant sells counterfeit products through multiple online platforms Ideavillage Prods. Corp v. 123LOPF//V, 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 239765. Finally, you would need to consider the effectiveness of the defendant's anti-counterfeiting measures. If the defendant has misrepresented the effectiveness of its anti-counterfeiting measures, this could support a claim of fraud Asay v. Pinduoduo Inc., 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 56179.
  • Customs and Border Protections: Register trademarks with customs authorities. This registration helps customs officials identify and seize counterfeit goods entering the country.

4. Working with Online Platforms

  • Collaboration: Work closely with online platforms to take down counterfeit listings. Platforms like Amazon have vested interests in maintaining trust and often collaborate with brands to address counterfeit issues.
  • Test Purchases: Make test purchases to confirm the authenticity of questionable products. This evidence can support claims in legal actions or reports to the platform.

5. Educational Campaigns

  • Consumer Awareness: Educate consumers about how to identify genuine products. This can reduce demand for counterfeit items, thereby reducing their prevalence online.

Legal Considerations

  • Jurisdictional Challenges: Counterfeiters often operate across international borders, which can complicate legal action due to varying laws and enforcement standards in different countries.
  • Evidence Collection: Maintain thorough documentation of infringements, including photographs, purchase records, and communications, as this evidence is crucial for legal proceedings.
  • Immunity under s.230 of CDA: Online platforms generally claim immunity based on section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (they may turn a blind eye) but Courts are starting to find the platforms liable for product liability, in spite of section 230.

By combining proactive monitoring, legal actions, and close collaboration with online platforms, companies can significantly reduce the impact of counterfeit products on their brand and revenue. These steps also help maintain customer trust in their products, which is critical for long-term success.

Part II: Taking Action against Counterfeit Products on an Online Platform like Amazon

Taking action against counterfeit products on an online platform involves a structured and strategic approach, which typically includes several steps. Here’s a detailed framework on how to proceed:

1. Identify and Document Infringements

  • Monitor Listings: Regularly scan online platforms for unauthorized listings that infringe on your trademarks or sell counterfeit versions of your products. Use tools provided by the platform, or invest in third-party services that specialize in monitoring and enforcement.
  • Document Evidence: Collect evidence of the counterfeit listings, which should include screenshots, product descriptions, seller information, and any customer reviews indicating the product is counterfeit.

2. Utilize Platform's Anti-counterfeit Measures

  • Report Through Official Channels: Most platforms, like Amazon, eBay, Alibaba, etc., have mechanisms for rights holders to report counterfeit goods. Use these mechanisms to file detailed reports, providing all necessary documentation and specifying the nature of the infringement.
  • Join Protection Programs: Enroll in any available brand protection programs (like Amazon’s Brand Registry), which provide additional tools and support for tackling counterfeit issues.

3. Engage with the Seller

  • Cease and Desist Notices: Send a cease and desist letter to the seller involved in the counterfeiting activity. This letter should demand that they stop selling the counterfeit products and remove the listings.
  • Negotiation: In some cases, engaging directly with the seller to resolve the issue amicably can be effective, especially if it seems to be an isolated incident or misunderstanding.

4. Legal Action

  • Consult an Attorney: Speak with a legal professional who specializes in intellectual property law to understand your options and the potential for success in legal actions.
  • File a Lawsuit: If the infringement continues or is on a large scale, consider filing a lawsuit for trademark infringement, unfair competition, and other relevant claims.
  • Customs and Border Protection: Register your trademarks with customs authorities to prevent the importation of counterfeit goods.

5. Enhance Brand Protection Strategies

  • Educate Customers: Use your website, social media, and other communication channels to educate your customers about how to identify authentic products and the dangers of counterfeits.
  • Improve Packaging and Authentication: Implement unique identifiers, holograms, QR codes, or other authentication methods to help distinguish genuine products from counterfeits.

6. Follow Up and Adjust Strategies

  • Assess the Outcome: Regularly review the effectiveness of your anti-counterfeiting measures and adjust your strategies as needed.
  • Stay Informed: Keep up-to-date with new tools and legal developments in the fight against counterfeits.

By following this structured approach, a brand can protect its intellectual property, maintain its reputation, and ensure that customers receive genuine products.

Older Post Newer Post

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published